0 items in Cart

Home
Menu
Gallery
Contact

Order Online
0 items in Cart

Home
Menu
Gallery
Contact
Order Online

Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Petey Wheaty’s Online Ordering Menu

145 S Main St
New City, NY 10956

1:30 PM - 11:00 PM

Start your carryout or delivery order.

Check Availability

Menu Icon Legend

SPECIALS

Mac 'n' Cheese a la Kel

Cheesy, creamy, delicious homemade mac 'n' cheese. This is Petey Wheaty's daughter's recipe, who he calls Kel!

FROM THE FRYER

Chicken Tenders

Breaded chicken strips, juicy and succulent on the inside and crispy on the outside.

Breaded clam strips, fried and served with tartar sauce.

Mouthwatering meat- and plant-based Argentinean-style empanadas.

Mozzarella Sticks

Battered mozzarella sticks, crips gooey, and delicious. Served with marinara sauce.

SALADS

Kale Edamame Chickpea Salad

Fresh kale, edamame, and chickpeas, dressed in a light vinaigrette and served over baby spinach.

Mediterranean Couscous Salad

Tender and plump Israeli couscous, walnuts, and cranberries, dressed in a light vinaigrette and served over baby spinach.

PERFECTLY SOUTHERN

Southern fried chicken like mama used to make!

Chicken Tenders

Macaroni 'n' Cheese

Sweet Potato Mash

Mashed Potatoes

Buttermilk Biscuit

MILTI'S SANDWICHES

Breaded Chicken Sandwich

Juicy breaded chicken breast served on Martin's potato roll.

BBQ Chicken Sandwich

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

BURGERS & GRILL

Burgers are a 6oz mix of chuck, short ribs, and brisket, pasture-raised and made locally.

Chucky Cheeseburger

As if the classic burger couldn't get any better, this one has cheese.

Dairy-free + gluten-free bread available. A delicious veggie burger for all our veggie friends.

Quesadilla Deluxe

Quesadilla of choice, served with a side of fries.

Pat La Frieda Hamburger

A classic grilled and juicy 6oz burger, served on a Martin's potato roll with pickles.

Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled Cheese on Martin's Potato Bread

Petey's grilled cheese on a Martin's potato bread, served with a crunchy pickle.

Beef Quesadilla

HOT DOGS

1/4lb Hebrew National, 100% beef, natural casing hot dog served on a Martin's potato roll.

Our classic dog served with a delicious savory chili on a Martin's potato roll.

Dog 'n' Onion Sauce Dog

Our classic 4oz Hebrew National, 100% beef, natural casing hot dog. This juicy and flavorful dog is served up on a Martin's potato roll.

SIDES

1040 Hwy. Southern Fries

MARILYN'S BROWNIES

Made with Ghirardelli chocolate and M&Ms.

CRUMB CAKES & COOKIES

Per slice. Moist Streizel crumb cake with great cake bottom.

Chocolate Chip Cookies (6)

Homemade PW chocolate chip cookies.

ICE CREAM

Eleanor's Hot Fudge Sundae

Classic sundae with your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. We recommend adding a warm brownie! :)

Hard-Serve (Cup)

Soft-Serve (Cup)

Your choice of any flavor of our hard ice cream, blended with milk.

Your choice of hard ice cream flavor served over a banana and topped with hot fudge, whipped, a cherry, and two toppings.

Ice Cream Float

Ice Cream Sandwiches (6)

Delicious and creamy homemade ice cream sandwiches. Available in vanilla in chocolate!

BEVERAGES

Gold Peak Iced Tea

House-Made Hot Brew Coffee

Piping hot and freshly-brewed breakfast blend.

Your cart is empty.

Accepts Google Pay

Accepts Venmo

Visit our Facebook

Powered by Menufy © 2023

Accessibility
Terms
Help
Privacy

Loading, please wait.