0 items in Cart
Petey Wheaty’s Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Contact
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Contact
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Petey Wheaty’s Online Ordering Menu

145 S Main St
New City, NY 10956
(845) 708-5030
1:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability
Menu Icon Legend

SPECIALS

Mac 'n' Cheese a la Kel 
Cheesy, creamy, delicious homemade mac 'n' cheese. This is Petey Wheaty's daughter's recipe, who he calls Kel!
$8.99

FROM THE FRYER

Chicken Tenders 
Breaded chicken strips, juicy and succulent on the inside and crispy on the outside.
$10.99
Clam Strips 
Breaded clam strips, fried and served with tartar sauce.
$12.99
Empanadas 
Mouthwatering meat- and plant-based Argentinean-style empanadas.
$5.49+
Mozzarella Sticks 
Battered mozzarella sticks, crips gooey, and delicious. Served with marinara sauce.
$9.99

SALADS

Kale Edamame Chickpea Salad 
Fresh kale, edamame, and chickpeas, dressed in a light vinaigrette and served over baby spinach.
$9.99
Mediterranean Couscous Salad 
Tender and plump Israeli couscous, walnuts, and cranberries, dressed in a light vinaigrette and served over baby spinach.
$9.99

PERFECTLY SOUTHERN

Fried Chicken 
Southern fried chicken like mama used to make!
$11.99+
Chicken Tenders 
$14.99+
Macaroni 'n' Cheese 
$5.25
Sweet Potato Mash 
$5.25
Coleslaw 
$4.99
Mashed Potatoes 
$5.99
Side of Gravy 
$3.99
Buttermilk Biscuit 
$1.99
Baked Beans 
$4.99
Side of Sauce 
$1.00

MILTI'S SANDWICHES

Breaded Chicken Sandwich 
Juicy breaded chicken breast served on Martin's potato roll.
$10.99+
BBQ Chicken Sandwich 
$11.99+
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich 
$11.99+
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich 
$11.99+

BURGERS & GRILL

Burgers are a 6oz mix of chuck, short ribs, and brisket, pasture-raised and made locally.
Chucky Cheeseburger 
As if the classic burger couldn't get any better, this one has cheese.
$12.99+
Binster Burger 
Dairy-free + gluten-free bread available. A delicious veggie burger for all our veggie friends.
$9.99+
Quesadilla Deluxe 
Quesadilla of choice, served with a side of fries.
$12.99
Pat La Frieda Hamburger 
A classic grilled and juicy 6oz burger, served on a Martin's potato roll with pickles.
$10.99+
Chicken Quesadilla 
$7.89
Grilled Cheese on Martin's Potato Bread 
Petey's grilled cheese on a Martin's potato bread, served with a crunchy pickle.
$6.99
Beef Quesadilla 
$9.99

HOT DOGS

Classic Dog 
1/4lb Hebrew National, 100% beef, natural casing hot dog served on a Martin's potato roll.
$8.99+
Chili Dog 
Our classic dog served with a delicious savory chili on a Martin's potato roll.
$9.99+
Dog 'n' Onion Sauce Dog 
Our classic 4oz Hebrew National, 100% beef, natural casing hot dog. This juicy and flavorful dog is served up on a Martin's potato roll.
$10.99

SIDES

French Fries 
$4.49
Cheese Fries 
$5.99
1040 Hwy. Southern Fries 
$5.99

MARILYN'S BROWNIES

Brownie 
Made with Ghirardelli chocolate and M&Ms.
$6.99

CRUMB CAKES & COOKIES

Crumb Cakes 
Per slice. Moist Streizel crumb cake with great cake bottom.
$5.50
Chocolate Chip Cookies (6) 
Homemade PW chocolate chip cookies.
$5.99

ICE CREAM

Eleanor's Hot Fudge Sundae 
Classic sundae with your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. We recommend adding a warm brownie! :)
$8.50+
Hard-Serve (Cup) 
$14.69+
Soft-Serve (Cup) 
$6.00
Shamster Shake 
Your choice of any flavor of our hard ice cream, blended with milk.
$8.26+
Banana Split 
Your choice of hard ice cream flavor served over a banana and topped with hot fudge, whipped, a cherry, and two toppings.
$11.05
Ice Cream Float 
$6.25
Ice Cream Sandwiches (6) 
Delicious and creamy homemade ice cream sandwiches. Available in vanilla in chocolate!
$15.99

BEVERAGES

Fountain Drink 
$3.25+
Bottled Water 
$3.50
Gold Peak Iced Tea 
$2.99
House-Made Hot Brew Coffee 
Piping hot and freshly-brewed breakfast blend.
$2.99+
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


  • Visit our Facebook
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.